The Balochistan High Court on Friday declared deli
mitation of eight provincial constitu
encies in Quetta null and void.
A divisional bench comprising Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghan and Justice Abdullah Baloch ordered the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to re-conduct deli
mitation in view of apprehensions and reservations of the political parties.
The constitu
encies are PB-24, PB-25, PB-26, PB-27, PB-28, PB-29, PB-30 and PB-32 – all located in Quetta district. However, there was no complaint about PB-31.
The number of constitu
encies in Quetta jumped from six to nine following the 2017 census. Almost all political parties had expressed reservations
regarding the recent deli
mitation by ECP in Quetta district.
Pakhtoonkhwa Milli Awami Party (PkMAP) leader Nasrullah Zarai, Hazrat Omar and Malik Yaseen had challenged the deli
mitation.
The court also ordered the shifting of union council Sorod from PB-44 Awaran/Panjgoor to PB-43 Panjgoor.
Meanwhile, Islamabad High Court (IHC), while hearing a petition
regarding the deli
mitation of constitu
encies, on Friday asked the ECP to decide the disputes on June 4. The court, disposing of identical petitions against the deli
mitation of constitu
encies, directed the petitioners to approach the ECP to redress their grievances on the said date.
Justice Farooq this week decided on 110 petitions in which the petitioners had challenged the ECP’s notification
regarding deli
mitation of their respective constitu
encies.
Justice Farooq on Friday set aside deli
mitations of district Abbottabad – which
was challenged by outgoing deputy speaker of National Assembly Murtaza Javed Abbasi – Zhob, and Jhang. He upheld the ECP’s decision on Sialkot and Multan’s constitu
encies.
Earlier on Wednesday, the IHC had declared the deli
mitation of Kharan, Ghotki, Kasur, Sheikhupura, Bahawalpur and Haripur void.
On Tuesday, the IHC had set aside the deli
mitation of constitu
encies in four districts – Jhelum, Jhang, Toba Tek Singh and Lower Dir.
The court had remanded all these cases back to the ECP for rehearing.
The IHC has so far set aside deli
mitation of 14 constitu
encies while almost an equal number of decisions of the ECP in this
regard have been upheld by the court. However, there are still 16 petitions pending before the court, which have been fixed for hearing on June 4.
In the written order, Justice Farooq observed that the ECP “while hearing the matter, has to take into account that the population variation should not be more than 10 per cent, however, where such is the case, reasons have to be given under section 21 (3) & (4) of the Elections Act, 2017.’
The court noted “under the scheme of deli
mitation, after th
e committee prepares and approves its proposal, the matter is to be forwarded to the ECP which scrutinises the same and can suggest alterations. If it does so, the matter is referred back to th
e committee for reconsideration of the amendment suggested. Once th
e commission is satisfied that the approved proposal for deli
mitation is convenient to the public, then it publishes the same along with its report in the official gazette.”
“Representations are then invited from the voters registered in the constitu
encies for changing the approved proposals. In this
regard, while considering the representations, the ECP has to see whether any amendment or change can be made and if it does feel so, it can be ordered accordingly,” the court order states.
Published in Daily Times, June 2nd 2018.